Voices from Russia

Sunday, 26 June 2011

SVS: The Revolt of the Ivory Tower Solons Against the Church… Just Where DOES ADS Fit Into It All?

Filed under: Christian,history,Orthodox life,religious,Russian,USA — 01varvara @ 00.00

ADS (and his “ghost”) has been the Pied Piper of Yonkers for nearly 50 years… isn’t it time to end it all?


Yesterday, as I was reading some asinine juvenile criticisms of St Yevgeni Rodionov and of the evolving revision of Church Slavonic in the MP, it struck me how detached from ordinary real-world reality it all was. However, should that surprise us? We shouldn’t delude ourselves… not only has SVS ploughed its own furrow since the death of Leonty Turkevich in 1965, there are elements in the ROCOR that have “run free” since the death of Anastassy Gribanovsky, also in 1965. Comments such as those that I read yesterday are nothing but the repulsive blossoms of a noxious root that’s been in the ground for over two generations. We’re going have to “go back to the beginning” to make any sense of it all.

Indeed, Aleksandr Dmitrievich Schmemann (ADS) had a strong and domineering personality… on the one hand, he was an extremely brilliant and fascinating charismatic individual (as many evil people are, sadly enough)… on the other, he was wedded to idiosyncratic and crackbrained notions of Church “renewal” and theology planted by his mentor, Sergei Nikolaevich Bulgakov (SNB). Although Bulgakov was his main guiding light, as SNB was a leading figure at St Sergius in Paris when ADS was a student there, the heretical writings of Pavel Aleksandrovich Florensky (PAF) and Aleksandr Ivanovich Vvedensky (AIV) also influenced ADS, as well. Did SNB introduce ADS to the works of PAF and AIV? Considering ADS’ later energetic defence of the ideas of the two named heretics, it’s probably likely.

Now, ponder this… in 1955, ADS stabbed Georgi Vasilyevitch Florovsky (GVF) in the back in a rather vicious example of academic politics… in 1935, GVF signed a vehement condemnation of SNB’s squiffy theology, don’t you think that this had something to do with ADS’ later betrayal of him? In fact, if GVF had a visceral loathing for Sophiology (and most Renovationist ideas, in general), why would he have sponsored ADS to come to New York in 1951, if ADS was a loud protégé of SNB? ADS had NO academic reputation at the time, indeed, he didn’t have any until the late ‘50s or early ‘60s, at the earliest, getting his main “leg-up” from outside boosters in the PECUSA (later, TEC) and Roman Catholic theological circles.

Of course, there are those who say that ADS’s career didn’t take off until the arrival of Ivan Feofilovich von Meyendorff at SVS in 1959… ADS was always a prickly sort… Ivan Feofilovich, being of the old Baltic nobility, facilitated ADS’ path in many ways (in contemporary Russia, whilst von Meyendorff is considered a competent scholar, ADS isn’t so well regarded). It’s interesting, as an aside, to note that both ADS and von Meyendorff were atypical Russian Orthodox clergymen, especially in terms of social status (ADS being of the Old Tsarist upper-middle class and Ivan Feofilovich was a noble). This goes a long way to explain why this duo was able to bamboozle both the Metropolia hierarchy and their impressionable students. To say that these two were “smooth articles” is an understatement.

As for me, I believe that GVF brought ADS to New York as a favour for Dmitri Schmemann… if one looks at the lives of ADS and of his identical twin brother Andrei, it strikes one as how opposite in temperament they were. Up to this point, Andrei was the “ideal son” of a White Guard officer… cadet NCO at the Nikolai II Gymnazia, active in the Vityaz (Russian Knight) organisation, a blood-and-soil Russian patriot. Although there’s no documentary evidence for this, I believe that ADS was a rebel and the “black sheep” of the family. Firstly, he became a clergyman… ADS was from the “officer class”… as I pointed up earlier, that was NOT DONE. Priests were a lower order… they were nothing but high-powered peasants, they weren’t even on the Table of Ranks (unless they were hieromonks or bishops who were already of the noble estate). No matter what the source, it’s clear that ADS made himself unwelcome in Russian Paris. Considering his later outbursts, stoking of conflict, and nasty hectoring of those who opposed his notions, it’s all too probable. Personally, I believe that his bitter personal feud with Georgi Grabbe dates from his Parisian years, and it may even have been the reason for his “exile” to New York. Make no mistake on it… North America was a place where you sent failures, ne’er-do-well Sad Sacks, and impenitent troublemakers. In Orthodox terms, it was Ultima Thule, the Back of the Beyond.

Again, note that GVF brought ADS to New York in 1951. Byzantine manoeuvring with the Metropolia bishops in 1955 brought down GVF… ADS was the main beneficiary of his fall. We have satisfied the question of “Cui Bono”… ADS benefited from GVF’s dismissal, for there’s no doubt, ADS wouldn’t have climbed as rapidly had GVF remained at the helm of SVS. Don’t forget, GVF was acidly critical of ADS’ mentor, SNB. I should also mention that, in 1935, both the ROCOR and the MP condemned SNB’s ideas as heretical (but declined to anathematise SNB personally, which is actually a typical move in Orthodoxy). Here are translations of the two documents:

Decree of the Moscow Patriarchate

By our decision of 24 August 1935, No 93, it was determined:

  1. The teaching of Professor and Archpriest S N Bulgakov… which, by its peculiar and arbitrary (Sophian) interpretation, often distorts the dogmas of the Orthodox faith, which in some of its points directly repeats false teachings already condemned by conciliar decisions of the Church, and the possible deductions resulting from which could even prove dangerous to spiritual life… this teaching is to be recognised as alien to the Holy Orthodox Church of Christ, and all its faithful servants and children are to be cautioned against an acceptance of this teaching.
  2. Those Orthodox Reverend Archpastors, clergy, and laity who have indiscreetly embraced Bulgakov’s teaching and who have promoted it in their preaching and works, either written or printed, are to be called upon to correct the errors committed and to be steadfastly faithful to “sound teaching”.


Decree of the ROCOR

Decision of the Bishops’ Council of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad of the 17/30 October 1935 concerning the new teaching of Archpriest Sergei Bulgakov on Sophia, the Wisdom of God:

  1. To recognise the teaching of Archpriest Sergei Bulgakov on Sophia the Wisdom of God as heretical.
  2. To inform Metropolitan Evlogy of this Decision of the Council and to request that he admonish Archpriest Bulgakov with the intention of prompting him to publicly renounce his heretical teaching concerning Sophia and to make a report about the consequences of such admonition to the Synod of Bishops of the Russian Orthodox Church Abroad.
  3. In the event that Archpriest Bulgakov does not repent, the present Decision of the Council, which condemns the heresy of Sophianism, is to be made known to all Autocephalous Churches.


ADS NEVER repudiated SNB… NEVER. He passed on his tainted ideas to an entire generation of students at SVS. If you look at many of the upper-level clergy in the OCA today, they’re men contaminated to the bone by contact with this hesiarch (it’s not true of many (if not most) “lower-ranking” clergy… adherence to ADS’ peculiar ideals have been a criterion for advancement in the OCA for years). ADS not only passed on Bulgakov’s open heresy, he passed on to his students an erroneous impression that the Church approved of AIV’s Renovationism and the loopy theology of PAF (do see Reardon’s open celebration of this heretic as “St Pavel Florensky”… God do help us!). Much of what you see emanating from SVS today is a result of ADS planting the seeds of heresy in the 60s and the 70s. Trust me, it takes a LONG time for such deleterious seed to bear its virulent fruit in all its fullness and ripeness. We’re seeing it today in the dysfunctional culture regnant in the OCA. Today, we have no one in a higher position that was in office during the healthier atmosphere that ruled in the time of Metropolitan Leonty.

Openly homosexual clergy and hierarchs… clergy who unblushingly divulge confidences from confession and counselling… clergy who openly solicit the blessing of Uniate hierarchs in public venues… THAT’S ADS’ legacy. It’s ugly, isn’t it? That’s why SVS has to go, and the sooner we put it down, the better. Otherwise, ADS’ rebellion will continue on, with unforeseen and incalculable consequence. God do have mercy on us…

Barbara-Marie Drezhlo

Sunday 26 June 2011

Albany NY 


Video. Russian Orthodox Rock… God is HAPPY and “Rocks”, Too… Let Everything That Breathes Praise the Lord!

Filed under: Christian,music,Orthodox life,performing arts,religious,rock,Russian — 01varvara @ 00.00


The frontman of this band is a priest… rock on, batiushka!



Video. Arkona and Rarog: Cossacks “Rock On”… Literally… URA!

Filed under: cultural,music,performing arts,rock,Russian,video — 01varvara @ 00.00




26 June 2011. No Comment Necessary… ‘Nuff Said… “What My Father Taught Me”

Filed under: domestic life,inspirational,moral issues,USA — 01varvara @ 00.00

The Letter in My Locker

I wrote a letter to my kids a few years ago. It’s three pages long, and it sums up what I’ve learned in four decades of life. My kids are too young to understand now, but by the time they reach adulthood, they’ll have heard most of the advice in that letter… live in the moment, don’t attach yourself to physical things, treat others the way you’d like to be treated, find happiness in the service of others, make the most out of today, follow your dreams, don’t take yourself too seriously, be aware that there are hypocrites and manipulators in the world, etc.

I sealed the letter in a plain white envelope, and wrote instructions not to open it unless something horrible happened to me. A Marvin the Martian magnet holds it to the side of my musty grey metal locker at work. It’s surrounded by police uniforms, spare change, “tribute of mourning” ribbons for my badge (to honour fallen colleagues), pictures of my kids, “The Far Side” cartoons, poems, scraps of paper with handwritten notes, business cards, dust, and lint… remnants of almost 20 years of serving others.

As a police officer, I’ve seen life snuffed out or irrevocably changed in an instant. I realise that could happen to me at any time. Yet, knowing that letter is there in my locker makes me more comfortable with my own mortality. If something does happen to me, my children will get that letter. In it, they’ll read about my love for them and about the advice that I want to pass on to them when they are old enough to understand it.

Every day, when I open my locker, I see the letter. It reminds me to be careful at work, and to show my children and the people I come into contact with that I truly understand and practice everything I’ve written. If that day comes, and my children finally read the letter, I hope that because of my actions, they’ll take my written beliefs to heart and improve upon my example.

Nevertheless, for me, it’s not enough to write down my beliefs. I try to be the best person I can be every day… even in very difficult circumstances, even with offensive people. I’m more successful some days than others. I curse too much, sometimes I’m cynical, and I don’t go to church as often as I should. I also get depressed, yell at my kids occasionally, and sometimes I’m not as loving or as compassionate as I should be. In fact, I’m far from perfect, but I hope my children will eventually realise that perfection is an illusion. What really matters is that, instead of just writing about our beliefs, we’ll take action to be the best humans we can be.

17 June 2011

Tim Wilson

The Week


Next Page »

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.